columbine – podictionary 1028

Sep 25th, 2009 | podcasts
 
 Standard Podcast [5:00m]: Play Now | Download

Here’s a word that gives us a lot to think about and I see most of those topics laid out on the new media dictionary site wordnik.

SPONSOR: Try GotoMeeting free for 30 days! For this special offer, visit  www.gotomeeting.com/podcast

They’re pretty smart those wordnik people, they’ve arranged for postings of images from Flickr alongside snippets from Twitter alongside traditional dictionary definitions from such sources as the American Heritage Dictionary and the Century Dictionary. So what I see when I type the word columbine are three pretty different meanings depending on source.

What did you think of when you heard this podictionary episode was going to be about the word columbine?

I bet you thought about the high school tragedy.

colombine

Or, if you’re a gardener you might have thought about flowers.

I searched Twitter in a little more depth than shown at wordnik and found almost all of the Twitter users who used the word columbine were using it with some kind of context relating to the high school shootings. There were dozens of mentions on Twitter within the last 24 hours of when I checked and this is more than ten years after the incident.

The photos on Flickr, however, are almost all of flowers; a much nicer visual image.

The flower columbine is the state flower of Colorado and that’s why the high school was named Columbine.

So this word has essentially gained a new meaning out of the tragedy.

I see it being used in phrases like columbine kids and columbine nightmare. These users are not talking about flowers.

Curiously the phrase columbine massacre dates back to 1927 when a miners’ strike also in Colorado got out of hand and machine guns were used.

But there is an older meaning to the word; etymologically columbine means “pigeon-like” or “dove-like.”  

Columba was “dove” in Latin.

We can ponder the peaceful symbolism of doves in the context of two events called massacres but instead let’s examine how a word to do with doves got to be attached to flowers.

Something similar has happened with the word iris which had an association with rainbows and so was applied to a kind of flower that came in many different colors. If you look at the feathers on a pigeon’s neck as it’s bobbing around trying to grab things from your downtown picnic, you’ll see a pretty side to that ugly bird. The feathers shimmer in a rainbow of different colors. So perhaps it was that a kind of flower that appears in various colors deserved the name columbine based on the many colors of a pigeon’s neck.

The Oxford English Dictionary doesn’t say this exactly, but instead gives examples of things other than these flowers being called columbine based on being “dove colored.”

The OED gives another theory why these flowers might be named after doves. One of the characteristics of columbine flowers is that they have five spikes or horns and the argument is that this resembled five pigeons clustered together.

This seems a pretty unconvincing association to me.

Just to show that you can see whatever you want in the meaning of things, it turns out that back around Shakespeare’s time 400 years ago columbine flowers got a bad reputation as having something to do with the seamier side of sex. It was those five horns on the flower.

3 Comments »

Comment by JP Maher

September 25, 2009 @ 10:00 am

“‘Columbine massacre’ dates back to 1927.” Better said, the 1927 and 1999 coinages are independent of each other. By the same token, the Roman poet Ennius [239 BC ca. - 169 BC] used the Greek “petra” for stone. But what gave us French (la) pierre, Italian pietra, Spanish piedra, was not Ennius’s use of the word; it was the pun in the Vulgate, with Jesus saying “tu es Petrus et super hanc petram aedificabo ecclesiam meam / Thou art Peter and upon this rock I will build my church”. By the same token there is no defensible evidence, if you investigate primary sources and don’t simply xerox the dictionaries, for “crap” (defecate) before Thomas Crapper & Co. And there is no defensible evidence for “hooker” (prostitute) before General Joseph Hooker’s Civil War story. Wordsmiths caught up in antedating and debunkery do not investigate primary sources. They don’t do their homework.

Comment by Kate

September 27, 2009 @ 8:12 pm

If you look at the flower, it seems to be a collection of 5 separate flowers. Each flower looks like a dove, and the 5 together look like 5 doves touching their beaks together.

Isn’t iridescent the word that came from iris, that describes the pigeons’ coloring?

Comment by Adrian Morgan

October 1, 2009 @ 1:43 am

Your Australian readers will generally have thought of “columbines” the caramel confectionery.
http://www.greataussiefood.com.au/showProduct/Food/Lollies/PACOL/Pascall+Columbines+200g+bag

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>